The bank safe deposit box is often perceived as an absolute security solution for the most valuable assets. While this image is partly justified, the contractual relationship between the customer and his bank is much more complex than simply renting a secure space. It is a specific service, governed by rules that have been largely defined by case law, and failure to observe them can have serious consequences. The assistance of a lawyer specialising in banking and finance law is often useful in navigating these subtleties. The purpose of this article is to provide an overview of this particular contract, clarifying its nature, the conditions under which it was formed, and the rights and obligations arising for each party. The safe deposit box service is part of the general framework of services offered by credit institutions.
What is a bank safe-deposit box contract? Definition and specific features
A safe deposit box contract is an agreement whereby a credit institution makes a secure compartment available to a customer in return for the payment of a fee. The customer can deposit objects or valuables in the safe for safekeeping. The particularity of this contract lies in its legal nature, which has long been the subject of debate.
A sui generis operation: a far cry from a deposit or lease
It is very tempting to characterise the safe deposit box contract as a lease or deposit. However, case law has rejected both of these descriptions. It is not a rental contract, because the customer does not have free and peaceful use of the safe deposit box. Access to the safe deposit box is conditional on the banker's assistance and is limited to the bank's opening hours. In addition, the bank is under an obligation to monitor the safe deposit box, which is not the case with a standard lease agreement. Nor is it a deposit contract, as the banker does not hold the assets. The customer himself places his effects in the compartment, without the bank knowing their nature or value. In the absence of physical delivery of the goods, the classification as a deposit is therefore inappropriate. Faced with this situation, the doctrine and the courts now agree that the contract is a "deposit". sui generisIn other words, it is an original operation with its own legal regime, shaped by court rulings.
Practical importance and development (history, digital safe)
The origins of safe deposit boxes date back to antiquity, but the bank safe service as we know it became widespread at the end of the 19th century. It meets a fundamental need for discretion and protection for valuable assets. Despite the emergence of individual safe deposit box solutions, the banking service has retained its appeal because of the security associated with the image of banks. Today, the trend towards dematerialisation is pushing banks to innovate. They are now offering digital safe deposit box services, designed to store and secure electronic documents and data, adapting a traditional service to new uses.
Forming the safe deposit box contract: parties, duration and price
The safe deposit box contract is governed by specific rules that define the relationship between the bank and its customer. The personal nature of the agreement and the nature of the obligations arising from it explain the rigour of these formalities.
The parties: sole holder, multiple holders or authorised representative (legal capacity)
The contract is concluded intuitu personaeThis means that the bank chooses its customer and is free to refuse to enter into the contract. In most cases, the safe-deposit box is held by a single owner. However, the holder may authorise a third party, known as a proxy, to access the safe-deposit box. The safe deposit box may also be opened in the name of several holders. In the case of a joint tenancy, access requires the presence of all the joint holders. For greater flexibility, the joint tenancy arrangement, which is common between spouses, allows each joint holder to access the safe-deposit box individually. In all cases, the parties must have legal capacity to enter into such a contract.
Contractual features: membership contract, duration and price
In practice, the safe-deposit box contract is a contract of adhesion. The bank proposes pre-drafted terms and conditions that the customer accepts without being able to negotiate them. The duration of the contract is variable. It may be concluded for an indefinite period, in which case either party may terminate it by giving notice. It can also be for a fixed term, often one year, with a tacit renewal clause. In the latter case, the law requires the bank to inform the customer of its option not to renew the contract. The price of the service, or fee, is set freely by the bank. Customers must be given sufficient notice of any price increase to enable them to terminate the contract and take their business elsewhere.
Rights and obligations of the safe deposit box customer
Signing the safe deposit box contract confers a set of rights on the customer, but also imposes specific obligations that must be met to ensure that the service is provided properly.
Payment of fees and right of use
The customer's main obligation is to pay the fee, which is generally annual and payable in advance. In return, they enjoy a right of use over the compartment made available to them. They are free to deposit any movable property there, with the notable exception of dangerous or illicit items, although in practice the secrecy surrounding the contents of the safe deposit box makes this prohibition difficult to control. Unlike a traditional tenant, the holder of the safe deposit box is under no obligation to furnish it.
Assignment, subletting and transfer of rights
Because of the intuitu personae of the contract, any transfer or subletting of the safe is prohibited. The customer may not transfer his right to a third party. However, the contents of a safe deposit box may be transferred, in particular by means of a manual donation. The handing over of the keys to the donee during the donor's lifetime may, under certain conditions, constitute an irrevocable dispossession and thus validate the donation.
Banker's obligations and liability
The banker is not simply a space renter; he is bound by onerous obligations which are at the very heart of the service offered and which make him highly liable in the event of any breach.
The credit institution has a fundamental obligation to monitor and control access to the safe-deposit box. It must check with the utmost rigour the identity and authorisation of any person accessing the safe-deposit box, even if that person is in possession of the key. Simply holding the key does not constitute a warrant. This monitoring obligation is described as an obligation of means, but it is assessed very severely by the courts. The banker is also bound by the strict rules of banking secrecyThere are exceptions, however, to allow access to the judicial or tax authorities within specific legal frameworks.
What is more, the banker has an obligation to ensure that the safe deposit box is preserved and that its contents are safeguarded. This is an obligation of result. This means that the banker must take all necessary measures to protect the assets against theft, fire, flooding or any other deterioration. This duty of care is so fundamental that the banker's liability with regard to safes is assessed very strictly by the courts, which only very rarely accept grounds for exoneration such as force majeure.
Unwinding the safe deposit box contract
The safe deposit box contract may be terminated for a variety of reasons, again subject to specific rules. Termination may be initiated by either party, subject to reasonable notice in the case of an open-ended contract, or in the event of misconduct on the part of the customer, such as non-payment of fees. Complex situations may arise in the event of the death of the holder, a seizure or in the event of inheritance, subject to the following conditions specific procedures that it is essential to master. In the event of death, the bank must block access to the safe-deposit box until the status of the heirs has been established, usually by notarial deed. At the end of the contract, the customer must empty the contents of the safe-deposit box and return the keys. If they fail to do so, the bank may, after serving formal notice, arrange for the contents to be opened by force in the presence of a bailiff.
Solent avocats: your expert in banking contract law
The unique legal nature of the safe deposit box contract and the stringent obligations it imposes can be a source of disputes. Whether challenging the bank's liability following a claim or managing the complexities of an inheritance, the expertise of a lawyer is often indispensable. Our firm, with its dedicated banking law practice, assists its clients in asserting their rights and defending their interests.
The relationship with a banking institution, even for a service that seems as simple as the safekeeping of goods, is based on a precise legal framework. For an in-depth analysis of your situation and tailored advice, contact our team of lawyers.
Frequently asked questions
Is the safe deposit box contract a deposit or rental contract?
No, it qualifies as a contract sui generis. It is neither a rental, because the customer does not have free and permanent access, nor a deposit, because the banker is unaware of the contents and does not take direct possession of them.
Does my banker know the contents of my safe-deposit box?
No, secrecy is a fundamental principle of this service. The banker has no knowledge of the contents of the safe deposit box, except in exceptional cases provided for by law, such as a seizure or forced opening procedure in the presence of a bailiff.
Can I give someone else power of attorney to access my safe-deposit box?
Yes, it is possible to appoint a proxy by means of a written power of attorney. The bank must then verify the identity and authority of this person each time access is requested, in accordance with its supervisory obligation.
What is the usual duration of a safe deposit box contract?
The duration is variable. The contract may be for an indefinite period, terminable with notice, or for a fixed period (often one year) with a tacit renewal clause. The customer must be informed of the option not to renew the contract.
EN 
FR