The purchase of a property is often conditional on obtaining finance. French law has introduced a major protective mechanism for non-professional buyers: the condition precedent for obtaining a mortgage. This clause, incorporated into the promise to sell, renders the contract null and void if the loan is not granted. This is a fundamental provision for the protecting borrowers on home loans. But what happens in practice if the seller refuses to finance your purchase? What are the seller's obligations and what recourse do you have if the sums you have advanced are not returned to you? The involvement of a expert lawyer in mortgage law can prove decisive in asserting your rights.
The principle of full and immediate reimbursement
When the suspensive condition of obtaining a loan is not met, the law provides for a return to the previous situation. The preliminary contract (promesse or compromis de vente) is deemed never to have existed. The direct consequence of this is that the seller is obliged to repay any sums paid by the buyer.
Legal basis (L. 313-41 Consumer Code)
The basis of this protection is article L. 313-41 of the French Consumer Code. This public policy text, from which the parties cannot derogate, is unequivocal. It states that if the suspensive condition is not fulfilled, "any sum paid in advance by the purchaser to or on behalf of the other party is immediately and fully repayable without deduction or indemnity on any grounds whatsoever".. The legislator's intention in using this wording was to protect the purchaser-consumer from a commitment that he can no longer finance and to ensure that he does not suffer any financial penalty as a result of the failure of the condition.
No deductions or compensation
The adverb "in full" and the precision "without deduction or indemnity" are of capital importance. They mean that the vendor may not retain any part of the sums paid by the purchaser. Any clause in the promise of sale to the contrary, such as a flat-rate indemnity for the immobilisation of the property or to cover administrative costs, will be deemed unwritten. The objective is clear: the failure of the financing transaction must not be transformed into a source of profit or compensation for the seller. The contract is retroactively annulled, and the parties must be returned to the state they were in before it was signed. Only a fault on the part of the purchaser, who through negligence or disloyalty has prevented the loan from being obtained, could justify an action for liability on the part of the vendor, but this does not authorise the vendor to retain the escrowed sums on his own initiative.
Scope of sums to be repaid
The law covers a broad area to ensure that the purchaser recovers all of his advances. Repayment is not limited solely to the earnest money or the advance on the purchase price.
Down payments, capital allowances, ancillary costs (architects' fees, etc.)
Any sum "paid in advance" as part of the planned property transaction is covered. Logically, this includes :
Immobilisation indemnity, generally paid when a unilateral undertaking to sell is signed.
The deposit, paid when signing a preliminary sales agreement.
However, case law has extended this scope to other costs. For example, deposits on architects' fees may be subject to repayment if they were included in the overall budget for the building project financed by the loan. Similarly, a deposit paid under a reservation contract for a VEFA (vente en l'état futur d'achèvement) must be repaid. The decisive criterion is the direct link between the sum paid and the property transaction that failed for lack of finance.
The role of the receiver and the terms of restitution
In practice, the sums paid by the buyer are rarely paid directly to the seller. Instead, they are entrusted to a sequestrator, usually the notary who draws up the deed. The role of this professional is to hold the funds until the sale is completed or, if the sale is unsuccessful, until the fate of the funds has been legally settled.
To obtain the return of the funds, the buyer must prove to the escrow agent that the suspensive condition has not been fulfilled. Production of the loan refusal certificates from the banks applied for is generally sufficient. If the seller and buyer agree that the deed of sale has lapsed, the escrow agent will return the funds without delay.
However, disputes may arise if the seller believes that the buyer is responsible for not obtaining the loan (non-compliant applications, failure to take steps, etc.). In this situation, the receiver cannot become the judge of the dispute. He retains the funds and will wait either for a written agreement from both parties, or for a final court decision ordering him to pay the funds to one party or the other. It is therefore essential to document precisely the steps taken to find financing so that you can prove your diligence.
Penalties for non-payment
The seller's refusal to return the sums due after the suspensive condition has been breached exposes it to significant penalties, both civil and criminal.
Criminal penalties: the fine incurred by the seller
The legislator has made it a criminal offence to fail to comply with this restitution obligation. Article L. 341-43 of the French Consumer Code imposes a fine of up to 300,000 euros on any seller who fails to refund the sums paid by the purchaser. This criminal sanction underlines the seriousness that the law attaches to this protection of purchasers and has a definite deterrent effect.
Civil penalties: interest at the higher legal rate
In civil law, the recalcitrant seller is penalised by late payment interest. Article L. 341-35 of the French Consumer Code provides a mechanism to encourage prompt repayment. The sum owed by the seller is subject to interest "at half the legal rate from the fifteenth day following the request for repayment". In practical terms, once the purchaser has made a request for repayment (ideally by registered letter with acknowledgement of receipt so that proof can be kept), a period of 14 days begins. Once this period has elapsed, increased interest starts to accrue, increasing the seller's debt for each additional day of delay.
What should you do if you are not reimbursed?
If, despite the clarity of the law, the seller or receiver refuses to return the funds to you, it is imperative that you take structured action to assert your rights.
Out-of-court settlement and formal notice
The first step is to formalise your request. If you have not already done so, send the seller and the escrow agent a letter of formal notice by recorded delivery with acknowledgement of receipt. This letter must :
- Recall the facts: signature of the promise to sell, failure of the suspensive condition to obtain a loan (attach bank refusals).
- Quote the legal basis for your request, i.e. article L. 313-41 of the French Consumer Code.
- Demand full and immediate reimbursement of the sum paid, specifying the amount.
- Indicate that if the item is not returned within a specific period (for example, eight days), you will take the matter to court and that the late payment interest provided for in article L. 341-35 of the French Consumer Code will start to accrue.
This formal notice is an essential prerequisite for any legal action. It is sometimes enough to break the deadlock and is a key element in any legal proceedings.
Legal action and the role of the lawyer
If the formal notice has no effect, the next step is to take the matter to court. Here, the assistance of a lawyer becomes essential. He or she will first check that your case is sound, and in particular that you can prove that you took the necessary steps to obtain your loan. He will then gather together the supporting documents, draw up the summons and represent your interests before the competent court.
The aim of the legal action will be to obtain a decision ordering the seller to repay you the capital sum, plus interest for late payment, as well as damages for the prejudice suffered (costs incurred, abusive resistance, etc.) and reimbursement of your legal costs. The strength of the legal protection afforded to the purchaser means that the outcome of such proceedings is generally favourable, provided that the purchaser has not committed any fault.
The legal provisions governing the breach of a loan suspensive condition are robust and clearly designed to protect the buyer. Repayment of the sums advanced is a right, and failure to comply is heavily penalised. To ensure that your purchase project is secure and that your rights are fully respected in the event of a problem, we recommend that you call on the services of an expert in the field. expert lawyer in mortgage law is a major asset.
Sources
- Consumer Code, in particular articles L. 313-41, L. 341-35 and L. 341-43.
- Civil Code.
EN 
FR