Navigation on France's rivers, canals and lakes is an important economic activity, whether for transporting goods or for tourism. Yet the insurance that covers these activities is often overlooked, overshadowed by its maritime or land-based cousins. Navigating inland waters may present fewer apparent perils than the high seas, but the risks do exist: damage, accidents, pollution... Insuring your boat or cargo correctly is not an option, it's a necessity. River and lake insurance has its own set of rules, a unique legal regime that deserves to be understood.
The purpose of this article is to provide you with information on the specific framework governing this insurance in France. We'll look at why they don't follow all the usual rules of the Insurance Code, what specific provisions apply to them, and how the wider shipping and river transport environment directly influences your contracts. Understanding this legal landscape is the first step to choosing the right cover and sailing with peace of mind.
An insurance scheme like no other
When we talk about insurance in France, we often think of the general framework defined by the Insurance Code. However, river and lake insurance, like the marine insurance to which it is closely related, benefits from special treatment. This specificity stems from the very nature of the risks covered, linked to navigation and goods transported on water.
A special place in the Insurance Code
The first particularity of river and lake insurance is its partial exclusion from the common system of land-based insurance. Article L. 111-1 of the Insurance Code clearly states that many of the general rules governing insurance contracts (Titles I, II and III of Book I) do not apply to marine, river and lake insurance. Imagine a house with certain rooms subject to different layout rules from the rest: that's the idea.
So where can you find the applicable rules? Mainly in Title VII of Book I of the Insurance Code, initially devoted to marine insurance but extended to cover river and lake insurance as well. However, even within this title, certain maritime provisions do not apply to inland waterways, as we shall see.
To complete this picture, the law has created a specific chapter, Chapter IV of Title VII, entitled "Special rules for various types of river and lake navigation insurance". These articles (L. 174-1 to L. 174-6) establish the legal bases for the main types of contract: hull insurance (the boat itself), cargo insurance (the goods) and liability insurance.
In addition to these legislative texts, it is important to stress the fundamental role played by insurance policies themselves. These are the standard contracts, drawn up by insurers often in consultation with professionals in the sector, which define the precise scope of cover, exclusions and the obligations of each party. They are the practical reference for day-to-day use.
Rules inspired by land-based insurance that still apply
Even if the regime is specific, river insurance is not totally isolated from ordinary law. Some important articles of the Insurance Code do apply, and they are of public order (they cannot be derogated from by contract).
Among these, article L. 111-6 classifies certain river risks as "major risks". This covers insurance for the vessel itself ("corps de véhicules lacustres et fluviaux"), the associated civil liability and the goods carried. This classification has practical implications, notably by facilitating the freedom to provide services for insurers within the European Union.
Article L. 112-2 also applies. It imposes information obligations on the insurer before the contract is signed: it must provide you with an information sheet on prices and cover, as well as a draft contract. It also governs the way in which the contract is formed.
The actual form of your insurance policy must comply with certain requirements, as set out in article L. 112-4. For example, clauses providing for nullities, forfeitures or exclusions of cover must be set out in very clear characters to be valid.
Finally, if you take out insurance with an insurer established in another European Union country (freedom to provide services), article L. 112-7 requires you to be clearly informed of the country where the insurer is established and its address.
The link with marine insurance: common rules and exceptions
The Insurance Code states that river and lake insurance contracts are subject to the provisions of Title VII, which governs marine insurance (article L. 171-1). There is therefore an important common basis. However, this same article immediately specifies that certain specifically maritime provisions are excluded for river insurance.
Why these exclusions? Because the realities of inland navigation are different from those on the high seas. For example, article L. 172-5, which cancels insurance taken out after a claim has been made if the news could have been known, does not apply to inland waterways. Similarly, article L. 172-11, which lists the risks covered by marine insurance (fortune of the sea, events of force majeure, etc.), does not apply unchanged to inland waterways, which have their own definitions of risks covered (see article L. 174-1 et seq.).
Other examples of notable exclusions concern general average (these exceptional contributions to save a maritime shipment), for which certain specific rules (L. 172-17, L. 172-26) do not apply to inland waterway transport. Insurance against "good arrival" (L. 173-7), which is typically maritime, is also excluded. Finally, certain cases of "abandonment" (abandonment of the ship or goods to the insurer in the event of a serious loss), such as failure to provide news for three months (L. 173-13 4°, L. 173-21 4°), have no direct equivalent in river insurance.
This link with the maritime sector, combined with these exceptions, underlines the hybrid and specific nature of the river insurance scheme.
Rules exclusive to rivers and lakes
To perfect this specificity, the legislator has therefore introduced rules specific to inland navigation, grouped together in articles L. 174-1 to L. 174-6 of the Insurance Code. Although these texts are succinct, they do ratify the rules governing inland navigation. main categories of insurance taken out by professionals :
- Insurance on the body (L. 174-1 to L. 174-3) : It covers damage to the boat itself. The law specifies the types of risk that are generally covered (sailing accidents, fire, explosion, etc.) and certain items that are covered (contribution to the cost of retirement if compulsory).
- Facultative insurance (L. 174-4) : It covers the goods being transported and provides cover for loss of or damage to property caused by shipping accidents or force majeure events, unless excluded by the policy.
- Liability insurance (L. 174-5 and L. 174-6) : Above all, the law recognises direct action by the victim against the insurer of the person responsible. This means that in the event of damage caused by an insured boat, the injured party can claim compensation directly from the insurer, without going through the boat owner.
There is one notable omission in these texts: despite the development of passenger transport (river cruises, tour boats), there is no general legal obligation for operators to insure their civil liability towards these passengers, unlike in other transport sectors. However, prudence and specific contracts often require such cover.
The legal environment: beyond the insurance contract
The river insurance contract does not live in a vacuum. It is profoundly influenced by the rules that govern its main activity: inland navigation itself and the transport of goods or people by river. It would be a mistake to ignore this context, as it has direct repercussions on the application of your cover.
The importance of inland navigation rules
By definition, river insurance applies to inland waterways. The Code du domaine public fluvial et de la navigation intérieure defines precisely what these navigable or floatable rivers and lakes are. Sailing outside these zones may result in a refusal of cover.
Beyond its geographical perimeter, inland navigation is subject to a complex set of technical and safety rules. Historically, international conventions such as the Mannheim Convention (for the Rhine, since 1868!) and the Belgrade Convention (for the Danube) have established the principles of freedom of navigation and common standards. Dedicated commissions monitor their application and adapt them.
The European Union also plays a major role. Numerous directives and regulations harmonise rules in a variety of areas: technical standards for boats, crew qualifications, working hours, recognition of diplomas, access to the market, etc. Compliance with these standards is often an implicit or explicit condition for valid insurance cover. A boat that does not comply with technical specifications could be refused compensation in the event of a claim.
Insurers therefore pay close attention to this regulatory environment, which partly defines the level of risk associated with a given type of sailing.
The direct impact of river transport law
When the insurance covers goods (cargo insurance) or the carrier's liability, the rules governing the river transport contract become decisive.
In France, the foundations of this contract are to be found in the Commercial Code (articles L. 133-1 to L. 133-7 in particular), which lays down the principles of liability of the common carrier. The 1982 Loi d'Orientation des Transports Interieur (LOTI) also played a structuring role, notably by providing for the creation of standard contracts.
These standard contracts, drawn up by decree after consultation with the industry, define standard clauses that apply automatically if the parties (shipper and carrier) have not precisely defined their relationship in writing. For river freight transport, standard contracts were approved in 1999 for subcontracting, "time" or "tonnage" transport. They specify the obligations of each party and, importantly for insurance, often set limits on the carrier's liability in the event of loss or damage to the goods. The carrier's liability insurance will take these limitations into account.
One notable development is France's ratification of the 2001 Budapest Convention (CMNI). Although mainly aimed at international transport, it could have an impact on domestic transport. In particular, it introduces a system of liability and compensation limits harmonised at European level, expressed in Special Drawing Rights (SDR). Developments in the application of this agreement will be monitored closely.
In practice, this means that the extent of the inland waterway carrier's liability (and therefore the corresponding need for insurance) will depend very much on the contractual framework chosen (standard contract or customised contract) and any limitations that may apply. A lawyer specialising in transport law can help you to clarify these aspects.
Understanding this general legal framework, with its specific features and links to maritime law, navigation regulations and transport law, is essential before delving into the details of the various river insurance policies. This will ensure that your needs are properly assessed and that you take out truly protective cover.
A complex legal framework requires a precise analysis of your insurance needs. To make sure your inland waterway business is properly covered, our team is on hand to provide you with a detailed analysis of your insurance needs. legal assistance.
Sources
- Insurance Code (in particular art. L. 111-1, L. 111-6, L. 112-2, L. 112-4, L. 112-7, L. 171-1, Title VII Book I, Chapter IV Title VII - art. L. 174-1 to L. 174-6)
- French Commercial Code (in particular art. L. 133-1 to L. 133-7)
- Code of the public river domain and inland navigation
- Budapest Convention on the Contract for the Carriage of Goods by Inland Waterway (CMNI)
EN 
FR